Nasty comments plague other papers, too
Vulgar, ill-considered and just plain mean story comments on Pilot Online are almost enough to make even a Founding Father to reconsider the whole "free speech" thing.
Some of the stuff that readers are leaving on our online content doesn't even come close to the standards we enforce for our print product. The fact that this stuff appears under the Pilot brand has caused heartburn for more than one staffer.
They're not alone.
Denise Bridges called my attention this week to a debate at The Washington Post described in Romenesko's column at Poynter Online. It's headlined "WPer wants online comments junked if they can't be filtered."
Post media columnist Howard Kurtz wrote:
Washingtonpost.com Executive Editor Jim Brady says he does not have the resources to screen the roughly 2,000 daily comments in advance. He has one staffer deleting offensive comments after the fact, and banning the authors from further feedback, based on complaints from readers. Brady plans to devote more staff to the process and to use new filtering technology.
"The medium allows for readers and journalists to engage in conversation, and to say we're not going to take advantage of that doesn't make a lot of sense to me," he says. "I'd rather figure out a way to do it better than not to do it at all."
Does the debate sound familiar?
Pilot Online now gets hundreds of story comments from readers daily and every one must be reviewed by an online producer. Comments that do not meet standards for taste, libel or civility are discarded, but those standards vary from producer to producer. As the number of comments grows, the amount of staff time spent on monitoring them grows, too.
John Robinson, the editor of The Greensboro News-Record, wrote recently about the same problem.
What's the proper response? Must we sacrifice our online forums because a few use it to express rage and hatred?
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home